Re: [jox] Clarification: review process

• From: Stefan Merten <smerten oekonux.de>
• Date: Mon, 24 Jan 2011 16:45:26 +0100

Hi Mathieu!

Yesterday Mathieu ONeil wrote:

1. Authors are not anonymous but reviewers are anonymous.
People who submit papers can not be not anonymous since submissions are openly discussed on the list.

Why is this necessary? Shouldn't the ideas be protected from openness?

Hope this helps to clarify, please point out any issues.

The initial process IMHO is really broken by design. The key would be
to not involve the mailing list for this but use the site from the
start. In addition the mailing list has another purpose and IMHO it is
needed for this purpose.


						Grüße

						Stefan

• Follow-Ups:
  • Re: [jox] Clarification: review process
    • From: Mathieu ONeil

• References:
  • [jox] Logo
    • From: Stefan Merten
  • Re: [jox] Logo
    • From: Athina Karatzogianni
  • Re: [jox] Logo
    • From: Maurizio Teli
  • [jox] 2010 Christmas Memo
    • From: Mathieu ONeil
  • Missing proposals (was: [jox] 2010 Christmas Memo)
    • From: Stefan Merten
  • Re: Missing proposals (was: [jox] 2010 Christmas Memo)
    • From: Mathieu ONeil
  • [jox] Re: Missing proposals
    • From: Stefan Merten
  • [jox] Launch update
    • From: Mathieu ONeil
  • Re: [jox] Launch update
    • From: Athina Karatzogianni
  • [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: Mathieu ONeil
  • Re: [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: Maurizio Teli
  • Re: [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: Mathieu ONeil
  • Re: [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: Athina Karatzogianni
  • Re: [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: Mathieu ONeil
  • Re: [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: nathaniel tkacz
  • Re: [jox] Urgent Message: Research papers
    • From: Athina Karatzogianni
  • [jox] Clarification: review process
    • From: Mathieu ONeil

• Next in thread: Re: [jox] Clarification: review process
• Previous in thread: Re: [jox] Clarification: review process
• First in thread: [jox] Logo
• Last in thread: Working on the web site (was: Re: [jox] Logo)
• Previous thread: [jox] open peer review
• Next thread: [jox] Publication update
• Next by Date: Re: [jox] Clarification: review process
• Prev by Date: [jox] Chaos or transparency?